Ghislaine Maxwell, Jeffrey Epstein’s close associate, might be close to leaving prison a free woman. Since Donald Trump returned to the presidency, she’s been navigating her legal battles with remarkable skill. Her lawyers argue she was unfairly charged because Epstein had a non-prosecution agreement with the government. That agreement said the U.S. would not charge any of Epstein’s co-conspirators. The legal question now is whether that promise applies to all federal prosecutors or only to the specific U.S. attorney who made the deal.

The Supreme Court is currently discussing which appeals they’ll hear in the new term starting October 6. If they decide Maxwell’s case needs review and she wins, she could walk free immediately with no retrial.

Some see this as almost like a pardon. Maxwell has already praised Trump and claimed he had no involvement in Epstein’s crimes, which got her transferred to a low-security prison. This legal route might allow her freedom without Trump having to personally pardon her, which would be politically risky for him. If she knows damaging information about Trump, this could give him some protection while still letting her go.

For her victims, however, this would be devastating. Maxwell was directly involved in Epstein’s crimes, and her release on a technicality would feel like a betrayal of justice. Her walking out of prison, smiling and getting into a waiting limousine, would be a crushing blow to those who suffered and a public embarrassment for the legal system. Under Trump’s return, the sense of justice already feels shaky, so Maxwell gaining freedom this way would be another painful blow.