The Supreme Court on Monday (September 15) orally observed that the acquisition of animals by Vantara — the Greens Zoological Rescue and Rehabilitation Centre run by the Reliance Foundation at Jamnagar, Gujarat — is prima facie within the regulatory mechanism.
A bench of Justice Pankaj Mithal and Justice PB Varale noted that the Special Investigation Team (SIT) led by former SC judge Justice J Chelameswar found no foul play in the process of acquiring animals from India and abroad, including elephants. “Acquisition of animals… carried out in regulatory compliance,” Justice Mithal said while going through the report during the hearing.
The Court emphasized that it was satisfied with the findings of the independent committee and made it clear that there should be no unnecessary allegations now that the SIT has confirmed compliance. Justice Mithal added, “If somebody wants to acquire an elephant and he takes care of the provisions of law and acquires, what is wrong in it?”
Confidentiality concerns raised
Senior Advocate Harish Salve, appearing for Vantara, and Solicitor General Tushar Mehta requested the Court not to publish the SIT’s report in full, citing commercial and propriety concerns over sensitive details of animal care. Salve argued that making the entire record public could fuel speculative narratives and impact the facility’s reputation globally.
However, the bench stated that it would accept the SIT report as part of its order and that all authorities are free to act upon its recommendations and suggestions.
Court closes the matter
The judges signaled closure of the case, appreciating the Committee’s work and suggesting that an honorarium be provided for its promptness. Justice Mithal observed that Vantara should be seen as something of pride for the country, adding that good initiatives must not be unnecessarily dragged into controversy.
The Court also refused to go into fresh objections, including issues raised about a temple elephant. “Allow certain good things to happen to the country. We should be happy about all these good things,” Justice Mithal said.
