Former Steelers Safety Ryan Clark has drawn heavy criticism online after leaving Tom Brady out of his “generational talent” list during a debate on ESPN. Netizens on X (formerly Twitter) accused Clark of being “racist” following his comments, which sparked a fiery discussion among fans and analysts.
Ryan Clark doesn’t think Tom Brady, Drew Brees, and Peyton Manning were generational talents
Football is so back pic.twitter.com/4Ws6Fj9h1u
— Barstool Sports (@barstoolsports) September 4, 2025
What Clark said
Clark argued that while John Elway, Patrick Mahomes and Andrew Luck should be considered generational talents, Tom Brady, Peyton Manning and Drew Brees do not fall into that category. “I think Patrick Mahomes is a generational talent. I don’t think Tom Brady. I don’t think Drew Brees. I don’t think Peyton Manning are generational talents,” he said.
Ex-Lions QB Dan Orlovsky pushed back, while Stephen A. Smith countered that “production” makes someone a generational player.
Backlash on social media
On X, many fans slammed Clark for disrespecting Brady, who is widely regarded as the greatest quarterback of all time. Some users went further, labeling Clark’s stance as “racist” and biased against white quarterbacks. Posts defending Brady pointed to his unmatched resume, including seven Super Bowl titles, multiple MVP awards, and all-time NFL records for touchdowns, passing yards and quarterback wins.
Ryan Clark is a full blown racist.
He is sooo mad that Dan Orlovsky called Arch Manning a “Generational Talent” because he is white.
Immediately brought up Lamar Jackson lol.#Espn #firsttake #Racist #NFL #Texas #Longhorns pic.twitter.com/g0gW3GuH9f
— 𝕯𝔢𝔫 𝘿𝙚𝙛𝙚𝙣𝙙𝙚𝙧 (@SheepleShunner) September 4, 2025
https://twitter.com/WarChest33/status/1963631135394496795
https://twitter.com/Michael_tHoover/status/1963630374493307183
https://twitter.com/FroemelAndy/status/1963715127141658800
Brady’s legacy in spotlight
Brady’s name continues to dominate debates around talent versus production. Despite Clark’s dismissal, Brady holds the NFL records for most touchdown passes, completions, games started and passing yards. He is also the only player to win Super Bowl MVP for two different teams.
The controversy over Clark’s comments has only reignited the generational talent debate — with social media ensuring Brady’s place in the conversation remains as strong as ever.
 
 
          