Harshit Rana’s unexpected promotion ahead of Shivam Dube in the 2nd T20I at the MCG has triggered a wave of criticism online, with fans questioning both the decision and head coach Gautam Gambhir’s strategy. The move, which saw the young pacer walk in at No.6 after India lost five wickets early, raised eyebrows immediately — and the backlash only intensified after the batting experiment failed.
Supporters voiced frustration, arguing that Dube, known for his finishing ability and six-hitting record, should have been the obvious choice in a pressure situation. Instead, Rana, still finding his feet at the international level, was thrust into a crucial phase — a call many felt was unfair to both players and damaging to the team’s momentum.
Social media quickly erupted, with users accusing Gambhir of prioritizing experimentation over match scenario awareness. Some pointed to India’s official team sheet, which had Rana placed at No.6, suggesting the plan was pre-decided and not dictated by match conditions. Others felt this trial-by-fire approach lacked clarity, especially with proven hitters like Dube waiting in the dugout.
India have been openly testing depth and role adaptability ahead of the 2026 T20 World Cup, but tonight’s move has left a section of fans unconvinced. With Rana under scrutiny and Dube underutilized, the experiment invites debate — whether bold tactical vision or avoidable risk, the verdict from netizens so far has been harsh.
Extra bounce at the MCG. And India guilty of not playing conditions or match situation. Harshit Rana coming out to bat in the 8th over itself is a sad reflection of Indian batting #INDvsAUS #MCG
— Vikrant Gupta (@vikrantgupta73) October 31, 2025
Harshit Rana on Batting in 8th Over😭 pic.twitter.com/0G9PUBLpwD
— Haydos🛡️ (@GovindIstOdraza) October 31, 2025
Harshit Rana ahead of Shivam Dube 😭🙏 pic.twitter.com/NYr151V1IC
— TukTuk Academy (@TukTuk_Academy) October 31, 2025
Harshit Rana is in XI again & India's all time highest wicket taker Arshdeep Singh is warming bench even on pace friendly pitch of MCG!!
Never seen this kind of blatant favouritism in India where players are sitting on bench even after achieving everything for franchise parchi! pic.twitter.com/QW8rMG53jr
— Rajiv (@Rajiv1841) October 31, 2025
You may ask why Harshit Rana is batting before Dube
Because he doesn't have a T20I batting average
So far 1 innings, 1 not out, 13* (8)
— Gaurav Sethi (@BoredCricket) October 31, 2025
https://x.com/GovindIstOdraza/status/1984185303838732729
 
 
          