Ever since The Paper landed on Peacock on September 4, 2025, fans of The Office vibe have been hooked. This mockumentary spinoff, cooked up by Greg Daniels and Michael Koman, swaps Dunder Mifflin’s paper game for the wild ride of a failing Midwestern newspaper, the Toledo Truth-Teller. Season 1’s 10 episodes left folks buzzing, and with Season 2 already greenlit, here’s the lowdown on when it might hit, who’s showing up, and what’s brewing for the plot.
The Paper Season 2 Release Date Speculations
Peacock didn’t waste time, giving Season 2 the go-ahead a day before the show even premiered. No exact date’s been spilled yet, but with production rolling, mid-to-late 2026 feels like a solid bet. Domhnall Gleeson and Sabrina Impacciatore dropped the renewal news on Today, hinting things are moving fast. Season 1 went from casting in April 2024 to filming by mid-2024, so a similar pace could land Season 2 around August or September 2026. Keep an eye on Peacock’s X or Instagram for fresh updates.
The Paper Season 2 Expected Cast
The Season 1 crew brought serious energy, and most are expected to return. Domhnall Gleeson’s Ned Sampson, the big-dreaming editor, leads the charge to save the paper. Sabrina Impacciatore’s Esmeralda Grand, the fiery managing editor, splits fans—some love her chaos, others think she’s a bit much. Chelsea Frei’s Mare Pritti, the compositor, and Melvin Gregg’s Detrick Moore, the reporter-ad guy, should be back, especially after those juicy romantic hints in the finale.
Others likely to pop up again:
-
Ramona Young as Nicole Lee, the lively newbie.
-
Gbemisola Ikumelo as Adeola Olofin, all heart and laughs.
-
Alex Edelman as Adam Cooper, the newsroom rookie.
-
Tim Key as Ken Davies, stirring trouble with strategy.
-
Oscar Nuñez as Oscar Martinez, the Office vet now crunching numbers.
Oscar’s the only confirmed Office crossover, but fans are itching for more. John Krasinski’s down to swing by, saying he’d “jump” at a Greg Daniels project. Jenna Fischer and Angela Kinsey, from Office Ladies, scoped out the set, sparking Pam or Angela cameo dreams. Steve Carell, though, says he’s sitting this one out, wanting the show to do its own thing. New faces could shake up the newsroom, but nothing’s confirmed yet.
The Paper Season 2 Potential Plot
Season 1 tracked a documentary crew—classic Office style—following the Toledo Truth-Teller’s fight to stay alive. Ned’s push for volunteer reporters butted heads with Esmeralda’s attitude and a quirky staff. The finale, “The Ohio Journalism Awards,” left two workplace romances hanging and the paper’s future shaky. Season 2’s likely to dive into those sparks, with Melvin Gregg teasing Detrick’s got some heavy emotional stuff coming. Expect Ned grappling with leadership, Esmeralda chasing power, and the team battling a brutal media world. The Toledo backdrop and mockumentary lens will keep the laughs weird and the drama real. Will Oscar get a bigger role? Any Office nods? Fingers crossed.
