1923, the Yellowstone prequel, hooked fans with its raw take on the Dutton family’s fight to hold their Montana ranch in the 1920s. With Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren leading the charge, the show’s gritty drama and stellar performances made it a Paramount+ hit. After Season 2’s emotional rollercoaster, everyone’s asking: Will there be a Season 3? Who’s coming back? What’s next for the Duttons? Here’s everything we know so far.
When Could 1923 Season 3 Hit Screens?
If Paramount+ gives the green light, don’t expect new episodes anytime soon. Season 1 dropped in December 2022, and Season 2 took until February 2025 to arrive—over two years later. Filming, especially with a cast as busy as Ford (working on Shrinking) and Mirren (tied up with MobLand), takes time. Add in Sheridan’s packed schedule, and a third season might not land until 2026 or even 2027.
Some blogs tossed around June 2024 as a release date, but that’s old news and doesn’t add up since Season 2 just wrapped. Best bet? Keep an eye on Paramount+’s socials or X for any official word. If production starts in 2025, late 2026 feels like a realistic target.
Who’s Coming Back for 1923 Season 3?
If Season 3 happens, the cast depends on who’s still standing after Season 2’s wild finale. Here’s a rundown of who might show up, based on where the story left off:
-
Brandon Sklenar as Spencer Dutton: Spencer’s the core of the show, now raising his son, John II, after losing Alexandra. The finale’s voiceover says he lives until 1969, so he’s a safe bet to lead the cast.
-
Harrison Ford as Jacob Dutton: Jacob pulled through the Season 2 shootout, though he took a hit. If the story picks up right after, Ford’s likely back, but his other projects might mean a smaller role.
-
Helen Mirren as Cara Dutton: Cara’s the heart of the ranch, stepping up to help raise John II. She’s a must for Season 3 unless the timeline jumps way forward.
-
Michelle Randolph as Elizabeth Strafford: Pregnant and headed to Boston after Jack’s death, Elizabeth’s story feels far from over. Randolph confirmed the pregnancy in a recent interview, so she could return for a big arc.
-
Aminah Nieves as Teonna Rainwater: Teonna’s headed west, maybe to the Crow Reservation. If she’s pregnant, her kid could tie into Yellowstone’s Rainwater family, making her a key player.
-
Brian Geraghty as Zane Davis: The ranch foreman’s arrest in Season 1 and his interracial marriage set up a juicy storyline. Season 3 could dig deeper into his fate.
-
Jennifer Carpenter as Marshal Mamie Fossett: The tough-as-nails marshal from Season 2 could cross paths with the Duttons again, especially if new trouble brews.
Julia Schlaepfer’s Alexandra won’t be back in the main timeline after her gut-wrenching death, but flashbacks could bring her into the mix. New faces, like a young John II or a fresh villain, might shake things up too.
What’s the Plot for 1923 Season 3?
Season 2 wrapped with Spencer saving the ranch and killing Whitfield, but losing Alexandra in the process. It felt like a big ending, but loose ends—like Elizabeth’s pregnancy and Teonna’s escape—scream for more. Here’s what a third season could dive into:
Spencer’s New Chapter: Raising John II alone, with Cara and Jacob’s help, won’t be easy. Killing Whitfield seemed too neat, so expect trouble from his shady business partners or the law sniffing around.
Elizabeth in Boston: A pregnant woman on her own in the 1920s? That’s a tough road. Her kid could be John III’s parent, tying straight into the Yellowstone family tree.
Teonna’s Next Steps: Teonna’s headed west, maybe starting a new life. If she’s pregnant, her story could build the Rainwater legacy, connecting to Yellowstone.
Fresh Threats: With Whitfield gone, someone new—maybe Banner Creighton’s kin looking for payback—could target the ranch. Drought and blizzards, huge in Season 2, might hit harder.
The Season 2 finale got flak for rushing things, with a voiceover tying up loose ends too quickly. Fans called it out on X, saying it felt like a shortcut. A third season could fix that, giving these stories the room they deserve.
