Michael Peña is sharing why his role in Peacock’s All Her Fault resonated with him on a personal and professional level. The acclaimed actor recently discussed how the emotional foundation of the series, combined with thoughtful writing and lived experience from its creator, led him to immediately commit to the project. His comments were shared during an exclusive conversation with Us Weekly at the 2026 Critics Choice Awards held in California on January 4, offering new insight into his creative decision-making and connection to the story.
Why Michael Peña Connected So Strongly With His Role in All Her Fault
Peña explained that All Her Fault creator Megan Gallagher personally reached out to him with a letter describing why the storyline mattered so deeply to her, noting that Gallagher is a parent to a child with special needs. He said that the emotional honesty behind the character of Detective Alcaras, who is a father to a nonverbal son with developmental disabilities, immediately stood out when he read the script. Peña shared that reading the episodes required a different level of attention, as early hints about his character’s family life gradually unfold before becoming central to the story in episode four. He emphasized that the writing felt purposeful and layered, making the character’s home life integral to the larger mystery rather than a background detail.
He also told that roles offering such emotional depth at home are rare, which made the opportunity especially meaningful. Peña noted that while he initially expected the series to be strong, the fourth episode elevated his excitement even further, confirming his belief in the project. According to the actor, that episode clarified how the personal storyline would later influence the broader plot, reinforcing his decision to say yes without hesitation.
Inside the Set Experience and Peña’s Praise for His Co-Stars
Peña also spoke warmly about working alongside his onscreen son, played by Orlando Ivanovic, describing the young actor as a standout presence whenever he was on set. He credited Ivanovic’s natural ability and professionalism for bringing authenticity to their scenes. Discussing the production pace, Peña said filming often involved long days, but the belief in the story kept the energy focused, even during the final hours of shooting.
The actor additionally reflected on collaborating with Sarah Snook, who stars as Marissa and won a Critics Choice Award the same evening. Peña shared that Snook’s performances consistently revealed nuances he had not anticipated when reading the script, highlighting her ability to add complexity and depth beyond what was on the page. All Her Fault, based on Andrea Mara’s novel and premiering in November 2025, follows a mother searching for her missing son after a seemingly ordinary playdate, gradually exposing unsettling truths within her inner circle. According to Peña, the series carries the intensity and intimacy of an independent film, a quality that continues to define its impact.
