Apple TV+’s Presumed Innocent wrapped up its thrilling first season with a jaw-dropping finale on July 24, leaving fans both satisfied and stunned. Based on Scott Turow’s bestselling novel, the show kept viewers guessing about whether it would stick closely to the book or deliver its own unexpected twists.
Presumed Innocent ending explained
In the finale, titled “The Verdict,” the courtroom drama reached its peak as Rusty Sabich, played by Jake Gyllenhaal, faced off in a high-stakes trial for the murder of Carolyn Polhemus. The episode kicks off with Tommy Molto (Peter Sarsgaard) discovering a fire poker on his kitchen counter, along with a threatening note that reads, “GO FUCK YOURSELF.” This discovery casts a shadow over Tommy, raising suspicions despite the lack of concrete evidence.
Rusty, despite his lawyer’s recommendation for a mistrial, opts to push through, determined to clear his name. During his closing statement, he boldly admits to his affair but maintains his innocence in Carolyn’s murder. The defense argues that Rusty has an alibi, challenging the time of death and asserting that he couldn’t have committed the crime. The courtroom holds its breath as the verdict is delivered: Rusty is found not guilty. There’s relief in the air, but Rusty is frustrated that Carolyn’s true killer remains at large. Tommy Molto, feeling defeated, is advised by Nico (O-T Fagbenle) to move on from the case.
The real shocker comes at home. Rusty, confronting Barbara (Ruth Negga) after finding a suitcase packed for a hasty departure, accuses her of being Carolyn’s killer. Barbara vehemently denies the accusation. The ultimate twist unfolds when their daughter Jaden (Chase Infinity) confesses to the crime. Overcome with rage after discovering Carolyn was pregnant with Rusty’s child, Jaden used the fire poker to kill Carolyn and then framed Tommy to protect her father.
The season concludes on a tense note. Rusty assures his family they will move forward and keep the ordeal behind them. The final scenes show the Sabich family attempting to resume normalcy with a Thanksgiving meal. Yet, a lingering glance between Rusty and Barbara hints at the deep-seated tensions and the heavy weight of their concealed truths.
