Sky Is Not The Limit, India Will Have To Go Beyond ASATs!

The asymmetric nature of space warfare, coupled with China’s substantial military satellite fleet, presents a daunting scenario for India. Responding to attacks on its space assets with kinetic interceptors risks exacerbating space debris, with potential implications for global space operations.

Around five years ago, India’s Ballistic Missile Defence Programme achieved a remarkable milestone, etching its name in the annals of space history. Against the backdrop of Abdul Kalam Island, an interceptor missile ignited, piercing through the atmosphere with fiery orange plumes trailing in its wake. In a matter of moments, it locked onto its target – a live Indian satellite named Microsat-R, orbiting 300 kilometres above the Earth’s surface.

The collision, a kinetic force to behold, shattered the satellite into countless fragments, marking India’s inaugural successful anti-satellite (A-SAT) test. This feat catapulted India into an elite echelon, becoming the third country globally to demonstrate this sophisticated capability. The spectacle of the missile’s majestic vertical ascent, culminating in the precise destruction of the satellite, underscored India’s burgeoning prowess in advanced missile technology.


In a nationally televised address, Prime Minister Narendra Modi heralded India’s A-SAT test as a pivotal achievement, hinting at its role as a deterrent against potential threats to the nation’s space-based assets. The implicit message was clear – India’s strategic move aimed primarily at countering China’s comparable capabilities, given Pakistan’s limited capacity in this arena.

Observers couldn’t overlook the historical context, recalling China’s analogous test in 2007, where a weather satellite met a similar fate at an altitude exceeding 850 kilometres. With this milestone, India joined a select cadre of nations fortified with the ability to defend their space assets, cementing strategic superiority in this critical sphere.

However, the A-SAT test wasn’t devoid of controversy. Criticism ensued regarding the substantial debris it generated, estimated at approximately 35,000 fragments larger than one centimetre. Among these, several sizable remnants, measuring up to four inches, are projected to orbit the Earth at high velocities for decades, posing potential risks.

Indian Air Force Chief Air Marshal V.R. Chaudhari had earlier emphasized the reality of the militarization of India’s space sector, highlighting its historical dual-purpose nature encompassing both civilian and military applications. Drawing parallels to the German V-2 rocket, Chaudhari underscored the evolution of space as a domain integral to strategic defense. Notably, he rebranded the Indian Air Force as the “Indian Air and Space Force,” aligning it with its French counterpart.

Chaudhari’s remarks echoed those of Indian Chief of Defense Staff (CDS) General Anil Chauhan, who emphasized the evolving nature of warfare in India. Chauhan advocated for the advancement of dual-use technologies, emphasizing the expansion of Navigation with Indian Constellation (NavIC) satellites to bolster India’s intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (ISR) capabilities.

These statements signify the securitization and militarization of space within India’s strategic discourse, where technology, assets, and infrastructure are increasingly geared towards military objectives. Key initiatives such as the establishment of the Defense Space Agency (DSA) and Defense Space Research Organization (DSRO) in 2019 underscore the integration of military space assets, particularly in enhancing ISR capabilities.

Furthermore, the launch of Mission Defense Space at DefExpo 2022 in Gujarat has catalyzed defense technology and space diplomacy, facilitating private sector involvement to drive innovation in the defense sector. India’s Space Policy 2023, while not explicitly referencing the military sector, advocates for bolstering space capabilities to safeguard national socio-economic development and security interests. The policy also emphasizes fostering greater private sector participation across the space value chain, signaling a holistic approach towards advancing India’s space endeavors.

U.S. – India Coorperation

The burgeoning cooperation between India and the United States, particularly in the defense and space domains, heralds a new era of strategic partnership and economic collaboration. The evolution of bilateral statements explicitly referencing the space domain within the realm of defense underscores the growing synergy between the two nations.

Traditionally reliant on Soviet/Russian imports for approximately 85% of its weapon systems, India has embarked on a path of diversification in defense procurement since 2010. Notably, U.S. military sales to India have surged to $7.93 billion between 2010-2017, a significant increase from the $1.39 billion recorded in the previous decade. The GE-F414 engines deal, slated to power the indigenous Tejas Mk2, along with the acquisition of 31 MQ-9B drones from the United States, signifies a deepening of the India-U.S. bilateral defense trade, expected to reach $25 billion.

India-U.S. dialogues within the space domain are poised to catalyze the development of defense industrial ecosystems, further augmenting the economic partnership between the two nations. As the United States emerges as India’s largest trade partner, with bilateral trade surpassing that of China-India trade, valued at $128.6 billion, India’s strategic realignment of supply chains away from China and Russia is set to bolster the defense industrial ecosystem.

Pacing Up With China

India faces critical challenges in its space defense strategy, particularly in responding effectively to potential threats from adversaries like China. While India has demonstrated its capability with kinetic anti-satellite (A-SAT) weapons, it is essential to acknowledge the limitations and explore avenues for further advancement.

The asymmetric nature of space warfare, coupled with China’s substantial military satellite fleet, presents a daunting scenario for India. Responding to attacks on its space assets with kinetic interceptors risks exacerbating space debris, with potential implications for global space operations.

To address these challenges, India must invest in a diverse array of kinetic energy weapons (KEWs), directed energy weapons (DEWs), cyber, and electronic warfare capabilities. These additional tools are vital for enhancing India’s deterrence posture and mitigating vulnerabilities in the face of evolving threats.

Given the strategic importance of space assets for India’s defense posture, especially amidst ongoing border tensions with China, the urgency to bolster space defense capabilities is paramount. While India has traditionally focused on leveraging space assets for reconnaissance and communication, recent developments underscore the imperative of developing robust counter-space capabilities.

Furthermore, India should actively engage in regional and global dialogues on disarmament and arms control measures concerning space weapons. Such initiatives can help mitigate the risk of an arms race in space while fostering a peaceful and stable space environment.

However, prematurely pursuing arms control and disarmament measures in response to China’s aggressive space posture may undermine India’s security interests.