Advertisement
Jojo Siwa’s transition from her iconic kid-friendly persona to a more mature image, reminiscent of Gene Simmons, hasn’t been without its challenges. While the former Dance Moms star has been open about her inspirations and favorite singers who influenced her evolution, her recent single release, “Karma,” has stirred up controversy, leading to speculation about its origins.
Songwriting in the pop music industry often involves collaboration among multiple artists, including singers, songwriters, and producers. “Karma” was crafted by the renowned songwriter Desmond Child and the music production duo Rock Mafia, known for their work with artists like Selena Gomez and Miley Cyrus.
The connection to Miley Cyrus is particularly intriguing. In 2010, Cyrus was undergoing a transition from her Disney image to a more mature persona, coinciding with the release of her album “Can’t Be Tamed.” It’s plausible that Cyrus, a source of inspiration for Siwa’s own evolution, was initially intended to sing “Karma.”
TikTok user @Adamtheflop presented evidence from a reputable Miley Cyrus fan page on X, suggesting that Cyrus had plans to release a single titled “Karma’s a B*tch” back in 2011. Cyrus’s interaction with Rock Mafia on Twitter seemed to corroborate this, although the song never materialized, possibly due to concerns over its compatibility with her PG image under Hollywood Records, a Disney-exclusive label.
Siwa’s pivot to a more edgy, adult persona has faced criticism, especially surrounding the release of “Karma.” While Cyrus has yet to address the controversy, she is no stranger to navigating internet backlash. Although there are no known versions of “Karma” by Cyrus, another singer attempted the tune in 2012, garnering praise on YouTube.