Advertisement
Studio Ghibli holds a near-mythical status in the world of animation. Founded in 1985 by legendary directors Hayao Miyazaki and Isao Takahata, the studio quickly earned global acclaim for its breathtaking visuals, whimsical storytelling, and philosophical depth. Films like My Neighbor Totoro, Spirited Away, Princess Mononoke, and Howl’s Moving Castle are often seen as masterpieces—not just of anime, but of cinema in general.
Ghibli isn’t just a studio. It’s a symbol of creative freedom, artistic purity, and anti-commercial storytelling. For decades, it has stood apart from the mainstream anime industry, which often relies on serialization, fanservice, and market trends. Ghibli, by contrast, insists on hand-drawn animation, original storytelling, and deeply rooted cultural themes.
And yet, for all the reverence Ghibli commands, some critics and younger audiences are starting to push back. They argue that many of Ghibli’s works are slow, plot-light, overly nostalgic, and emotionally inaccessible. Others claim the studio’s refusal to modernize has made it creatively stagnant or that it’s stuck in an outdated ideal of what anime “should” be.
So—is Studio Ghibli truly the pinnacle of animated storytelling, or is it living on reputation alone? This article explores both sides of the debate, challenging assumptions while also recognizing the studio’s undeniable contributions to global animation.
Ghibli’s Strength: Artistry and Atmosphere
There’s no denying the visual brilliance of Ghibli films. Every frame feels like a painting, with meticulous detail and naturalistic movement that elevate even the simplest scenes—like cooking, cleaning, or walking through a forest. Films like Kiki’s Delivery Service and The Wind Rises showcase a deep appreciation for everyday beauty, making the mundane feel magical.
Unlike much of mainstream anime, which often centers on action or romance, Ghibli films emphasize atmosphere, character introspection, and slow, immersive storytelling. Spirited Away isn’t just a coming-of-age tale—it’s a symbolic journey through childhood fears, cultural shifts, and identity loss. Princess Mononoke doesn’t offer easy heroes or villains; it explores environmental conflict with moral complexity.
Critics who adore Ghibli often cite its emotional subtlety, its refusal to explain everything, and its ability to transport viewers into alternate realities that feel oddly real. This storytelling style prioritizes emotion over exposition—an approach that fans argue is timeless.
The Criticism: Overrated or Overprotected?
While Ghibli’s artistry is often praised, it’s not above criticism. Some argue that its pacing can be painfully slow or that plots often meander without a clear resolution. Films like Ponyo, From Up on Poppy Hill, or The Cat Returns are sometimes viewed as beautiful but forgettable.
Others take issue with recurring tropes: absent parents, coming-of-age girls, non-verbal male characters, and quiet rural settings. While these can be themes of resonance, they sometimes feel overused, particularly across Miyazaki’s later works.
There’s also the issue of critical bias. Many film critics—especially outside Japan—place Ghibli on an artistic pedestal, often overlooking its flaws in favor of mythologizing its legacy. Some viewers feel pressured to like Ghibli, even if they find its films emotionally distant or thematically opaque.
Moreover, Ghibli’s reluctance to evolve with the industry is viewed by some as elitist. The studio famously avoided digital tools for decades and continues to resist streaming-first releases, collaboration with modern creators, or serialized storytelling. While this preservation of “purity” is admired by fans, others see it as stubbornness rather than integrity.
Comparing Ghibli to Modern Studios
To evaluate Ghibli fairly, it’s important to compare it to contemporary animation studios—both in Japan and abroad. Studios like MAPPA, Wit Studio, Ufotable, and Science SARU are pushing visual boundaries with dynamic action, CGI integration, and stylistic experimentation. Internationally, studios like Pixar, Laika, and Cartoon Saloon are creating emotionally resonant stories that rival Ghibli in depth and originality.
Ghibli’s style, while timeless, hasn’t changed much in 30 years. Critics ask: does consistency make a studio classic—or creatively complacent?
Newer anime films like Your Name (Makoto Shinkai), Belle (Mamoru Hosoda), and In This Corner of the World (Sunao Katabuchi) have received critical acclaim while offering more contemporary themes, modern aesthetics, and broader representation. In contrast, Ghibli’s worldview can sometimes feel rooted in a specific postwar Japanese nostalgia—charming to some, alienating to others.
The Miyazaki Effect: Genius or Gatekeeper?
Hayao Miyazaki is undeniably a master storyteller, but his towering influence over Ghibli has created both brilliance and bottlenecks. He writes, directs, and oversees most projects, and while this gives Ghibli its distinct identity, it also limits the studio’s creative range.
The studio’s other visionary, Isao Takahata (Grave of the Fireflies, Only Yesterday), brought a more grounded, adult tone that balanced Miyazaki’s flights of fantasy. With Takahata gone and Miyazaki aging—yet still working on new films—there’s concern about succession. Can Ghibli evolve beyond Miyazaki, or is it trapped in his shadow?
Films from Ghibli’s younger generation, like Earwig and the Witch by Goro Miyazaki, have not been well received—fueling skepticism about whether the studio can thrive without its original genius at the helm.
Is Reverence Preventing Innovation?
Perhaps the biggest reason some say Ghibli is overrated lies in how it’s treated—not by itself, but by its audience. The studio is often placed beyond critique, its flaws excused in favor of legacy. This near-sacred status can stifle innovation and discourage the studio from taking creative risks or hiring younger voices.
Meanwhile, the anime landscape has changed dramatically. Audiences want diverse stories, gender exploration, cultural fusion, and contemporary struggles. While Ghibli still has a place in that world, it can sometimes feel like it’s speaking to a past that no longer exists.
The adoration for Ghibli is earned—but it should not be unchallenged. When criticism becomes taboo, art loses its opportunity to grow.
Conclusion: A Legacy Worth Protecting—But Not Worshipping
So, is Studio Ghibli overrated?
The answer depends on what we mean by “overrated.” If we mean that its artistic and narrative achievements are inflated without critical examination, then yes—some of its reverence may be more about myth than merit. Not every film is a masterpiece, and not every theme is timeless.
But if we mean that its legacy is somehow undeserved, the answer is a firm no. Studio Ghibli has changed the world of animation. It introduced millions to anime, inspired generations of artists, and gave us stories of quiet power and visual poetry.
Still, as anime evolves and audiences diversify, it’s okay to question the throne. It’s okay to love Ghibli while acknowledging its blind spots. And it’s necessary to invite new voices, new visions, and new definitions of what anime can be.
Ghibli may not be perfect—but that doesn’t make it less important. It just makes it human.