Advertisement
Google has decided to reverse its plan to phase out third-party cookies, a move that has significant implications for advertisers and the broader internet landscape. Announced on Monday, this decision marks a shift from Google’s previous stance, where it aimed to end the support for these cookies, which are crucial for tracking users’ web activity and targeting ads.
What Are Cookies?
Cookies are small pieces of code delivered to a user’s browser by websites. They remain on the user’s device as they navigate the web, silently tracking their online activities. This data helps advertisers target ads more effectively based on users’ browsing behavior. According to data from W3Techs, approximately 40.9% of websites globally use cookies for data collection.
Cookies also play a vital role in the functionality of the modern web, such as keeping users signed in as they browse different pages. They contribute to the convenience of online experiences by ensuring that ads are tailored to individual interests, thereby supporting the free availability of content on the internet.
Google’s Initial Plan and Privacy Sandbox Initiative
Google initially sought to replace cookies with more privacy-focused alternatives through its “Privacy Sandbox” initiative, launched in 2019. One of the proposed replacements was the “Federated Learning of Cohorts” (FLoC), a system that would group users with similar browsing behaviors, thereby targeting “cohort IDs” instead of individual user IDs.
Despite being “extremely confident” about these new methods, Google repeatedly delayed the timeline for eliminating cookies, citing feedback from the advertising industry. The main concern was that the new systems might lead to less effective ad campaigns, affecting the digital advertising ecosystem that relies heavily on cookies.
The Decision to Keep Cookies
Ultimately, Google decided to maintain third-party cookies. The company acknowledged that the marketing industry was not ready for such a significant shift. Instead of eliminating cookies, Google plans to introduce a new experience in its Chrome browser that will give users more informed choices about their web browsing privacy settings.
“We’re discussing this new path with regulators, and will engage with the industry as we roll this out,” the company stated in a blog post.
Implications for the Internet and Advertising
For internet users, the immediate experience will remain largely unchanged. They will continue to encounter consent checkboxes asking whether they want to accept all cookies or only essential ones. However, for advertisers, the decision means they can continue to rely on the valuable data derived from tracking users’ web activities.
Steve Silvers, executive vice president of global creative, media, and ecosystem at Kantar, highlighted the economic implications, noting that the continuation of third-party cookies helps keep the internet free. Without cookies, many website owners struggled to monetize their audiences, leading to an increase in gated or paywalled content. Ironically, some media publishers might reconsider these paywalls in light of Google’s decision.
Reactions and Future Outlook
The decision has drawn mixed reactions. The U.K.’s Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) expressed disappointment, having worked closely with Google to develop alternatives that balanced user privacy with business needs. The ICO and the Competition and Markets Authority will continue to monitor the situation and may consider regulatory action if systemic non-compliance is identified.
Despite the decision, experts warn that this does not signal a return to “business as usual.” Vasiliki Makou, a digital strategist at the marketing agency Axicom, noted that the push for greater online privacy is not going away, driven by regulations such as the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Businesses are advised to stay vigilant and adapt to evolving privacy standards.