Advertisement
Season 2 of Nobody Wants This picks up right after Noah and Joanne’s reconciliation from Season 1. The couple tries to blend their lives together, but their religious differences soon rise to the surface. Noah becomes more deeply connected to his Jewish roots, while Joanne feels uneasy about converting. Things take a tense turn when Noah lies to his family and community, saying that Joanne plans to convert soon. This one lie becomes the heart of the conflict for the entire season, testing their relationship and values.
In the finale, Joanne still hasn’t officially converted to Judaism, but she starts to find her own connection to Jewish life. She celebrates Shabbat, enjoys traditional foods like challah and kugel, and slowly begins adopting small rituals that make her feel part of the culture. A touching conversation with Esther helps her understand that faith doesn’t have to come from strict rules or labels, it can grow naturally from the life you live. By the end, Joanne seems ready to start the conversion process on her own terms, hinting that Season 3 will focus more on her spiritual growth.
Their love story hits another obstacle when Joanne, facing eviction, asks to move in with Noah. He refuses, saying he can’t live with someone who isn’t Jewish. The fight leads to a painful breakup that feels both understandable and heartbreaking. But in a classic emotional twist, Noah soon realizes how wrong he was. He runs after Joanne, telling her that her faith doesn’t change how he feels about her. It’s a tender ending that shows love doesn’t always fit neatly within the boundaries of belief.
The season also gives more depth to the side characters. Sasha and Esther’s marriage falls apart after years of emotional strain and conflicting life goals. Morgan’s messy romantic life, including her troubling relationship with her therapist, highlights how power and vulnerability can blur lines in damaging ways. Meanwhile, Morgan’s surprising friendship with Noah’s mother, Bina, brings some humor and warmth to balance out the heavier moments.
By the finale, the stage is clearly set for Season 3. Joanne is stepping into a new phase of her faith, this time by choice, and Noah is learning to balance love with his evolving beliefs. Professionally, he faces his own inner conflict at Temple Ahava, a reform synagogue whose values clash with his conservative upbringing. Together, these threads promise that the next season will dive even deeper into how love, identity, and faith continue to shape their lives — and test their connection in unexpected ways.