Advertisement
Fiona Harvey, known as “Martha,” is set to continue her lawsuit against Netflix for defamation and misrepresentation related to the series Baby Reindeer. A recent ruling by Judge Gary Klausner determined that the series’ claim of being based on true events is inaccurate.
Harvey alleges that British screenwriter Richard Gadd, who created the show, made false statements about her, accusing her of abusing him, attempting to choke him, and being imprisoned for stalking. The drama escalated in July when Netflix sought a court injunction to dismiss the lawsuit. However, the recent ruling favored Harvey’s right to proceed with the case, particularly because Netflix labeled the show as a true story, despite its fictional nature. Reports from The Sunday Times suggest that this “true story” tag was added at Netflix’s insistence, despite Gadd’s reservations.
The judge noted that the show significantly distorted Martha’s character, stating, “There is a major difference between stalking and being convicted of stalking in a court of law.” He highlighted that there are also important distinctions between minor inappropriate actions and severe allegations like sexual violence, as well as between physical altercations and more extreme forms of violence.
While Harvey was never explicitly named in the show, viewers quickly recognized the similarities, prompting widespread speculation online. Judge Klausner commented on this, saying, “The Series states that Plaintiff is a convicted criminal who sexually and violently assaulted Gadd. These statements may rise to the level of extreme and outrageous conduct.” He also pointed out that while Harvey’s alleged actions were concerning, the statements made by the defendants could have a more damaging impact on viewers.
Although the judge dismissed Harvey’s claims related to negligence and violation of publicity rights, he did allow her to continue with her lawsuit focused on intentional infliction of emotional distress.
Despite the ongoing controversy, Baby Reindeer has emerged as both a critical and commercial hit. This six-time Emmy-winning British black comedy-drama thriller, directed by Weronika Tofilska and Josephine Bornebusch, debuted on Netflix on April 11, 2024, and has garnered a significant audience and positive reviews.