Did Donny sleep with Martha in ‘Baby Reindeer?’

Advertisement

Baby Reindeer’s rise to prominence on Netflix is certainly well-deserved, but it comes with a slight caveat for some viewers who may not have been fully prepared for the emotional journey it offers. The brilliance of the series lies in its ability to tackle challenging topics with a grounded approach, especially considering its autobiographical nature, which adds another layer of depth to the narrative.

One particular scene that left many viewers puzzled and perhaps uncomfortable was the encounter between Donny and Martha in Episode 5. In this scene, Donny appears on Martha’s doorstep and initiates a passionate interaction with her. However, this encounter is never addressed again in later episodes, leaving viewers wondering why.

The reason for this lack of follow-up is because the entire scene was a product of Donny’s sexual fantasy. After the police intervention relieved Donny of Martha’s persistent presence, he found himself longing for the chaotic intensity she brought into his life. This intensity served as a distraction from his own internal struggles, particularly his sexual trauma and self-loathing.

Advertisement

Donny’s fantasy involving Martha allowed him to maintain an erection so that he could engage in sexual activity with his girlfriend, Teri. Teri, who is portrayed as a supportive and understanding partner, is unaware of Donny’s underlying issues and assumes his struggles with intimacy are related to her being a trans woman. This miscommunication further strains their relationship.

In his self-destructive behavior and fantasies, Donny finds a temporary release from his internal turmoil, which is reinforced by the improved dynamics in his relationship with Teri. However, this only perpetuates the cycle of self-hatred and dysfunction.

Overall, Baby Reindeer delves into complex themes with nuance and honesty, shedding light on the intricacies of human psychology and relationships. It’s a compelling and thought-provoking series that resonates with viewers long after the credits roll.