Las Vegas Raiders hammered by NFL analyst for offseason decisions

ESPN’s Seth Walder minced no words when critiquing the Las Vegas Raiders’ offseason maneuvers, particularly honing in on their handling of the quarterback situation. General Manager Tom Telesco faced heavy scrutiny for failing to secure what many would consider a franchise-level quarterback for the long term.

Instead of landing a big-name quarterback like Kirk Cousins, who could potentially stabilize the position, the Raiders settled on Gardner Minshew and Aidan O’Connell to compete, neither of whom are seen as game-changers in the quarterback hierarchy. Walder, like many analysts, expressed disappointment in this approach, highlighting that while Minshew had a solid stint in Indianapolis, he doesn’t represent a definitive solution.

Advertisement

In defense of the Raiders’ predicament, Walder acknowledged the challenging landscape of quarterback acquisitions, noting the slim pickings in free agency and the uncertainties of drafting late in the order. Even if they had traded up, it likely would have been for a second-tier prospect. Nonetheless, the decision to commit $15 million guaranteed to Minshew drew criticism for its substantial investment without securing a clear future at quarterback.

The retention of Davante Adams without trading him for future draft assets was another sore spot for Walder. With Adams nearing the latter stages of his career and holding significant trade value, Walder argued that the Raiders missed an opportunity to bolster their draft capital for future quarterback pursuits. He also questioned the hefty expenditure on defensive tackle Christian Wilkins, suggesting it might not have been the wisest allocation of resources.

Amidst these critiques, Walder did find a bright spot in the re-signing of center Andre James, a move he deemed necessary and commendable.

Looking ahead, Telesco’s decisions will be under the microscope throughout the season. Should the Raiders falter early, Walder speculated they might pivot towards selling off assets to rebuild for the future—a strategy that hinges on the outcomes of their upcoming campaigns.

In essence, while Telesco’s offseason moves have drawn mixed reviews, their true impact will unfold as the Raiders navigate the challenges of the upcoming season.