Drama unfolded in Perth as England lost their seventh wicket in highly contentious fashion, with Jamie Smith given out caught behind despite what many felt was inconclusive evidence on UltraEdge. The dismissal — which came at a crucial moment with England 104/6 — has left the visitors visibly unhappy.
The incident occurred when Brendan Doggett bowled a delivery down the leg side, prompting an immediate appeal from Alex Carey. Umpire Sharfuddoula raised the finger, and Jamie Smith initially began walking before hesitating. Australia reviewed the on-field call, convinced there was a faint edge.
The replays, however, sparked confusion. The RTS (Real-Time Snicko) showed a spike after the ball had passed the bat — something even commentators noted looked unusual. Despite this, the third umpire deemed the deviation significant enough and upheld the out decision.
The reaction from the England camp — both on-field and in the stands — made their displeasure clear. The Barmy Army voiced their frustration as Smith walked off for 15 off 25 balls (1 four), shaking his head.
Smith’s dismissal added to England’s collapse, coming soon after Mitchell Starc’s 10-wicket match haul dominated the morning. At the time of the wicket, England were 104/7, leading by 144 runs, with the game slipping rapidly towards Australia’s control.
Australia, meanwhile, sensed the opening. The bowlers, led by Starc and Doggett, have dismantled England with relentless accuracy and movement, turning Day 2 into one of the most action-packed sessions of the Ashes so far.
More updates to follow as the controversy continues to simmer.
